If a video made with AI tools gets stolen and used to sell courses, can you sue for copyright infringement? A court in Chengdu has just answered yes — conditionally — and published the reasoning in enough detail that other creators can predict how it applies to their own work. The case appears among the first batch of 12 typical cases on private-economy protection that the Chengdu Intermediate People’s Court released with the city’s development-reform commission on November 3-4, 2026.
Six videos, one training business
The plaintiff, a culture-media company based in Shenzhen and anonymized in court records, had creators produce six short videos during 2024 — including works titled Snow and Flower, The Rain of Mountains and Wen Cheng Princess — using generation tools such as Jimeng and Kling. After publication, the videos drew substantial attention. The defendant, a Chengdu technology company selling paid AI-business courses, signed a promotion agreement with a third party; multiple accounts then reposted the videos with the plaintiff’s watermarks and source labels stripped, steering viewers through comment-section links to paid courses.
The two-part test
The Sichuan Free Trade Zone People’s Court, hearing the case at first instance, found the six videos qualified as audiovisual works under China’s Copyright Law. The standard it applied has two steps: continuous intellectual investment as the process test — independent scripting, iterative prompt and parameter adjustment, multi-round generation and selection, then editing, scoring and pacing decisions — and substantive expression transformation as the result test, meaning the creator exercised real control over narrative rhythm, transitions and sound-picture alignment rather than accepting whatever the model produced.
The court also rejected the defendant’s second defense, that it merely commissioned promotion and did not run the infringing accounts itself. A penetrating review of who planned, directed and profited from the distribution found joint infringement. Damages for economic loss and reasonable expenses came to 60,000 yuan. Neither party appealed; the judgment is final.
Not every AI image survives the same test
The verdict lands alongside a revealing contrast. In a separate recent case, the Kaifu District People’s Court in Changsha rejected a copyright claim over a single AI-generated image of a herbal sachet, finding the generation process lacked originality. Same underlying question, opposite outcome — and both courts, notably, reasoned through process evidence rather than treating AI output as automatically protected or unprotected. Both sit under the Opinions on adjudicating AI-related disputes that the Supreme People’s Court issued in September 2026.
The practical takeaway before the next ruling
For creators, the difference between the Chengdu and Changsha outcomes is documentation. The winning plaintiff could show drafts, prompt iterations, editing decisions and version history; the losing claimant apparently could not. Watch whether the two-part formulation — investment plus transformation — gets cited in the next round of AIGC rulings out of other provinces, and keep prompt logs and intermediate renders for anything you intend to commercialize, because that is now the evidence the courtroom asks for.